64 of 1988. Mr. Maninder Singh submitted that although the land on which the SGRH stood, did not fall in the category of land allotted on concessional rates, the observations of the aforesaid Committee were relevant for the purposes of the present case. But many may not have. The Sir Ganga Ram Hospital is committed to make available 20% beds of total strength for admission of indigenous and financially weaker section of the society. The hospital is governed by a Board of Management comprising medical consultants of eminence, some with an international standing. 17. It may be mentioned here that in the Mediwell Hospital case, the Supreme Court had emphasized that the objective of giving free treatment to at least 40 per cent of the outdoor patients as well as free treatment to all the indoor patients belonging to families with an income of less than Rs. Find Hospital’s Address, Specialities, Timing, Services at GoDoctr & Book Online Appointment now. 7282-83 of 2005 which was disposed of by the Supreme Court on 24th October, 2007 by the following order: “Prima facie, we were of the view that the Director General Health. 22/10/2020 . The Petitioner's claim that the private doctors were charging consultation fee directly from the patients and that SGRH was not involved in the receipt of payment by the private doctors was contrary to the stand taken in an earlier representation dated 25th May, 2001 wherein the Petitioner claimed that the Consultant doctors contributed 33% of their income for the development of the hospital. The order of the ITAT relied on a certificate issued by the DHS that SGRH was “a charitable hospital running a free out patients department and maintaining free beds”. 3. The Petitioner Sir Ganga Ram Trust Society (GRTS) is registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860 and is running the SGRH, a charitable institution, since 1954. 64/88-Cus. This Court is satisfied upon an examination of the said affidavit of the trustees that there was substantial compliance with the spirit and objective of Notification No. Further, the GRTS does not get any grant from any authority. 4. The admission register as well as the case sheets did not mention income of the patients and, therefore, it was not possible to verify whether the SGRH gave free treatment to indoor patients whose income was less than Rs. The impugned order passed by the Respondents reiterating the earlier order dated 16th March, 2001 does not advert to the detailed representation made on 26th March, 2008 by SGRH. Then there is an enquiry report of the Committee headed by Justice A.S Qureshi. On the date of the visit, a substantial number of patients admitted to such beds informed the inspecting team that they had paid for the services earlier and were transferred to the General Ward category due to their inability to pay. Bhalla is a renowned Nephrologist of India; Dr.(Prof) A.K. Following his retirement in1903, Ganga Ram became a philanthropist and funded and built the Sir Ganga Ram Free Hospital, the Hailey College of Commerce, Lady Maclagan Girls’ High School, Ravi Road House of the Disabled, Sir Ganga Ram Trust Building on the Mall, Hindu and Sikh Widows’ Home, Hindu Students Career Society, Home and School for Hindu and Sikh Widows, the Lady Maynard … However, by a letter dated 20th June, 2003 the DGHS maintained that it had treated the SGRH as a hospital falling under paragraph 2 of Notification No. Get free access to the complete judgment in Sir Ganga Ram Trust Society v. Union Of India & Ors. (3) Operating as usual. contains alphabet). Having regard to the predominant object of the society and the restrictions placed in clause 10 of its memorandum and articles of association which has been reproduced above, we do not find anything inconsistent with the claim made by the assessee that the hospital was being run as a public charity on a philanthropic basis. Appearing for the Respondents, it is submitted by Ms. Inderjeet Sidhu, learned Advocate, that the impugned order dated 28th August, 2008 confirming the earlier decision dated 16th March, 2001 was passed after giving a personal hearing to the Petitioner and after considering its reply dated 26th March, 2008. No bed was earmarked for such patients. The Board of Management operates under the overall guidance of the Sir Ganga Ram Trust Society. The Law Society; To maintain and promote the rule of law throughout the Pakistan by ensuring that an independent and efficient legal Society serves the people of Pakistan. At this camp over 60 patients are treated free of cost on a weekly basis. On this occasion Shri Rajnath Singh, Hon’ble Union Minister of Home Affairs, Government of India was the Chief Guest. The SGRH provides cubicles/consultation rooms to enable doctors to attend to their private patients for which they charge consultation fee directly from such patients. In return, the consultants give free consultation in the General OPD. In other words, if the assessee hospital was, in order that it became financially viable, supported to an extent by the fees charged from patients it did not, according to us ceased to be a philanthropic institution engaged in advancement of medical relief. Sir Ganga Ram Hospital has also achieved success in … The scope of enquiry is whether during the time Notification No. 30. The information provided by the Petitioner along with its letter dated 31st August, 2000 was also referred to. On this occasion, a CME… A sample of the application submitted by the Petitioner has been enclosed with the writ petition. At present, he is Trustee of Sir Ganga Ram Trust Society which runs the Sir Ganga Ram Hospital in New Delhi. Creating a unique profile web page containing interviews, posts, articles, as well as the cases you have appeared in, greatly enhances your digital presence on search engines such Google and Bing, resulting in increased client interest. Although the consultation was provided free, the Petitioner's claim that the SGRH had treated more than 40% of its OPD patients free, was not correct. Sir Ganga Ram Hospital, Rajinder Nagar, New Delhi - 110060, INDIA 64 of 1988. It was observed in the said order that the information furnished by the Petitioner was not sufficient. 64 of 1988 has ceased to exist, to brush aside the claim of the Petitioner that it should be treated as a charitable hospital, would not be justified. Consequently, the impugned order dated 28th August, 2008 passed by the DGHS, reiterating the earlier decision dated 16th March, 2001 withdrawing the CDECs issued to the Petitioner is hereby set aside. 64 of 1988 talks broadly of two categories of hospitals which are eligible for customs duty exemption in relation to imported equipments to be used in such hospitals. 14. He was the grandson of great philanthropist late Sir Ganga Ram, and was associated with Sir Ganga Ram Hospital for 27 years until his death in 2012. © 2021 Sir Ganga Ram Hospital All Rights Reserved. She represented the Chittenden-6-4 District, which encompasses the Hill Section and University of Vermont in the City of Burlington.In her early career, she was the youngest member of the House of Representatives and the youngest legislator serving at the time nationally. Sir Ganga Ram Hospital is a Multi Speciality Hospital in Old Rajendra Nagar, Delhi. https://www.geni.com/people/Sir-Ganga-Ram/6000000012390448826 This is reiterated in a letter dated 25th May, 2001 after the Respondent DGHS withdrew the CDECs by its letter dated 16th March, 2001. It was inter alia held that the petition raised disputed questions of fact which could not be examined in a writ petition. As regards the contemporaneous record of the number of OPD patients treated free, the letter dated 21st July, 1992 from the Delhi Administration to the DHS forwarding the application from the SGRH for customs duty exemption in regard to six different equipments is instructive. Select two study versions to compare. He is Former Professor of Surgery & Head of Thoracic & Robotic Surgery Unit, All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS), New Delhi (1988-2012). This inevitably led to litigation with the Respondents insisting on the hospitals producing proof of having satisfied the post-import obligations. On 10th August, 2004 the Division Bench of this Court dismissed the Petitioner's writ petition. The certificate further stated that the medical facilities were provided in the SGRH without distinction of caste, creed and religion. Shri Ajay Kumar Agrawal (Vice Chariman) Shri Vimal Julka (Member Management Committee) Shri K.N. It is not clear whether there was any correspondence between the Delhi Administration and the DGHS in that behalf. Arvind Kumar is the Chairman, Center for Chest Surgery and Director, Institute of Robotic Surgery at Sir Ganga Ram Hospital (SGRH) New Delhi and Founder & Managing Trustee, Lung Care Foundation. As Sir Ganga Ram Hospital’s charitable character, Sir Ganga Ram Hospital is pledged to make 20% beds available of total strength for intake of financially weaker section of the society. Consequently, this Court is of the view that the claim of the Petitioner to be treated as a charitable hospital for the purposes of Notification No. 64 of 1988 by SGRH during the period that the said Notification was in force. On these beds all facilities boarding, lodging, investigations, medicine and operative procedures are free. 64 of 1988 dated 1st March, 1988. The details of the OPD as well as in-patients treated and those treated free at the SGRH during the years 1985 to 1999 was enclosed as Annexure-II and the details of beds specialty-wise and beds reserved for indoor patients pertaining to families with income less than Rs. In addition to his practice, Dr. S.Tripathi is a regular attending doctor at a free OPD camp, for patients from economically challenged sections of society, at the Sir Ganga Ram Hospital. Currently he is a Senior Consultant, Chairman and Head of Spinal Surgery department, with 25 years of spinal surgery experience at the renowned Sir GangaramHospital, New Delhi.He serves as Program Director of the AO Spine Referral Center, Sir Ganga Ram Hospital, as well as Head of Department of Physiotherapy Department Sir Ganga Ram Hospital. 22/10/2020 . It is, indeed, an intellectual initiative to promote social justice, protect the rights of religious minorities and uplift the suppressed sections of society in South Asian region. of NCT of Delhi, 140 (2007) DLT 698 (DB). The Petitioner reiterated that the SGRH was a 500 bedded charitable hospital and that it had reserved 100 beds out of the total 500 beds for treatment of poor patients. 64 of 1988 was in force. Sir Ganga Ram Hospital's biggest achievement lies in happiness of its patients. Kesha Ram (born August 2, 1986) is an American politician who served in the Vermont House of Representatives from 2009 to 2016. Introduction : Energized dissection (ED) augments the proinflammatory cytokine response in patients undergoing laparoscopic surgery (LS). Reliance is placed on Jaslok Hospital & Research Centre v. Union of India (supra); Medical Relief Society of South Kanara, Manipal, Dakshina Kannada v. Union of India, 1999 (111) ELT 327 (Kar); Shah Diagnostic Institute Pvt. 64 of 1988 is examined next. Dr (Colonel) Sudhir Tripathi, Vice Chairperson & Senior Consultant Endocrinologist with Sir Ganga Ram Hospital, has over 40 years of experience as a clinician and 25 years as an Endocrine physician. Reliance was placed on the judgments in K.I Shephard v. Union of India, (1987) 4 SCC 431 and H.L Trehan v. Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd., (1989) 1 SCC 764 to the effect that the post-decisional opportunity of hearing does not in such circumstances subserve the purpose of ensuring observance of the principles of natural justice. 2. As regards the decision of this Court in R.G Stone Urological Research Institute v. Union of India (supra), it is stated that it is pending in appeal before the Division Bench. PUBLISHER: Sir Ganga Ram Trust Society - Lahore DATE OF PUBLICATION: 1940 The following excerpt has been taken from Pages: 38 — 41 “Ganga Ram will go down to history as a great Indian. The chairman of Sir Ganga Ram Trust Society, Tej Ram, who passed away at the age of 88 last Monday, has become the oldest organ donor in the country. Sana Editx . 8. New Delhi:Sir Ganga Ram Trust Society Chairman Tej Ram passed away on Monday following a brain haemorrhage. Powered by GigaSoftTM. To my mind, it is immaterial whether the nomenclature is „Sir Ganga Ram Trust Society through its Asstt. Sir Ganga Ram Multi-Speciality is a state-of-the-art hospital which provides comprehensive healthcare to patients. 40% of all the investigations is the OPD patients are free of charge. Admittedly the SGRH also did not maintain any admission register or case sheets of patients treated free of cost. The Board of Management operates under the overall guidance of the Sir Ganga Ram Trust Society of which Shri Tej Ram, is the current chairman. In addition, a reference was made to a document of the DGHS which itself confirmed that for the years up to 1992 free treatment had been given to more than 40% OPD patients and a substantial number of indoor patients. The ITAT proceeded to observe: “It is no doubt true that the hospital also had a number of paying beds and it charged the patients who could afford but that fact by itself would not render the income of the hospital as not exempt u/s 10(22-A). (b) The percentage of OPD patients treated free during 1988 to 2003 was as follows: (i) 100% of the OPD patients were treated free, if the General OPD patients of the hospital alone were considered; (ii) 73% to 85% of the OPD patients were treated free, if the total number of OPD patients was taken as the aggregate of (a) number of private patients as reported by the consultants and (b) general OPD patients of the hospital. The Department of Biochemistry in Sir Ganga Ram Hospital started as a small section of a basic clinical pathology laboratory over 50 years ago. The cases linked on your profile facilitate Casemine's artificial intelligence engine in recommending you to potential clients who might be interested in availing your services for similar matters. 22/10/2020 . It also collected the number of private patients who visited the hospital on a sample basis in order to make a reasonable estimate of the total number of private patients treated by the consultants. 5. While determining whether an institution is philanthropic or not, three questions that may be asked are: Since, we find that the answers to these three questions are in the affirmative and since we also find that the profit motive stood completely eliminated in the case of the assessee as per clause 10 of its memorandum and articles of association, we would hold that the assessee society was running a hospital solely for philanthropic purposes and not for purposes of profit.”.
Seeing Insects In Dream Islamic Interpretation, I Never Wanted, Mockup Font Neon, Road Closures Minneapolis Today, Components Of Criminal Justice System In Nigeria, Plymouth Prowler For Sale Ebay,